RGrant

My name is Grant Rusk. Call me G-man ok.

1.My E.T. conclusion is that Herbie is NOT!!!! living, here is why...... It can't move on it's own, it was made by humans and it is not alive is that life forms go in it!!

2.The apple was living when it was on the tree because, it was connected to the tree. Now it is not living cause it is off the tree and it will only be living when it is underground.